The Dangers of High Protein Diets

By Christina Major  |  23 January 2020   

High protein supplements and shakes dominate the bodybuilding, weight loss, and martial arts communities. However, many of these only succeed in stripping people of their money and giving false hope. At worst, they're incredibly detrimental to a person's health.

And you don’t build muscle consuming these products!

What is Protein? 

Supplement companies rely on people who want to build muscle and focus on “protein,” a nebula word that's about as specific as saying “carbs.” There are hundreds of different types of proteins that build muscle, bone, tendon, organs, neurons, and every structure in our body. Muscle is only one of those structures and requires a specific set of proteins to make it happen. All protein is built from amino acids. 

Protein Foods Pyramid | Fighting Arts Health Lab

There are 22 amino acids, with eight of them being essential we obtain through our diet. The others we can make on our own. But take that with a little skepticism. Because not only are there 22 basic amino acids, there are different configurations of those amino acids that our body uses.
Many people have seen the configurations of various amino acids, such as l-lysine and l-tyrosine. 

There is also a d-configuration. Our body needs all of them, so we need 44 different amino acids, although the d-configuration ones can be produced out of the l-configuration and only used in trace amounts.

Why Protein Supplements and Drinks are Bad for You

So now, we look at the different supplements and drinks you can get that are supposed to be high in protein. 

The problem with these drinks as you don’t know which amino acids are in there unless you do the nutritional homework to discover what the original composition was. Then, you have to go through the manufacturing process to see how amino acids got preserved. Finally, you have to know precisely how long the supplement was sitting on the store shelf before you purchased it.

That’s a lot of work, which you probably aren’t doing.

Whey is a Common Form of Protein 

This is the leftover fluid from the cheese industry. Here’s what happens to weigh between the time it comes out of the cow to make it into your supplements:

  • First, the milk is homogenized and pasteurized, which is a high heat and pressure system designed to destroy bacteria. Unfortunately, it denatures all of the protein within the milk.
  • The milk is then shipped to cheese processing factories where the milk is often heated again and then mixed with cheese cultures, rennet, and salt.
  • As the cheese begins forming, the cheese separates from the lower quality whey.
  • Now, this whey gets sent to protein processing plants where it gets pasteurized again under high heat, then dehydrated.
  • The dry product then mixes with preservatives, flavors, and other components before being shipped off to wait on the grocery store shelves.

Other forms of proteins go through similar processes. Products like soy, pea, and vegetable proteins go through mashing, cooking, and pasteurization before being ground down and then dehydrated.

Now, protein needs to be in its active form to be used properly by the body. Once it becomes denatured, such as during the pasteurization process, the protein is practically useless.

And that doesn't even start to go into all the other problems with soy and its link to cancer, thyroid disruption, and overstimulating estrogen, which inhibits muscle formation.

What is an Appropriate Protein Intake?

Men who are looking to build muscle should take in between 120 and 140 grams of protein per day. This equates to 5 oz or just under one-third of a pound.

To put that matter into perspective, one serving of chicken contains approximately 50 grams of protein. Fish and beef also have about 50 grams of protein for every 4 oz serving. One egg contains 6 grams of protein. One serving of yogurt, approximately 4 oz, contains 12 grams of protein.

Protein Structure | Fighting Arts Health Lab

That means you’ll eat need less than one pound of meat, or about 12 oz, per day to get enough protein to build healthy muscle. If you had two eggs for breakfast, a serving of yogurt as a snack, 4 oz of chicken at lunch, and 4 oz of beef at dinner, you will have accomplished your goal of eating enough protein to build strong muscles.

The best thing about eating a variety of whole food ingredients is that you get all of the amino acids you need. Mixing eggs and beef gives you the full array of essential amino acids and semi-essential amino acids without your body having to convert anything extra. Variety also takes the pressure off the kidneys, studies showing this amount of protein and diversification do not impair kidney function.

Protein supplements don't do that for you.

What Happens When You Get Too Much Protein?

Once you go over this protein amount, health problems begin. Your body uses the protein you need and eliminates the excess protein you don't – it removes the toxic levels of protein. The organs most involved with this detoxification are the liver, kidneys, and adrenal organs.

One of the most common diseases fighters, athletes, and martial artists face is kidney dysfunctions. The combination of excess protein and dehydration creates such stress on the kidney that leads to kidney stones, kidney disease, kidney and bladder cancer, and kidney failure.

Johny Hendricks Kidney Failure | Fighting Arts Health Lab

Source: Business Insider

In 2017, fighters Tony Murda Davis or Johny Hendricks were hospitalized with kidney failure.

Hendricks specifically stated, “That's what sucks more than anything, is that you work so hard to showcase what you have, and all of a sudden the diet that we were on backfires. 

Which sucks, but I've learned after we did this [recovery from kidney failure], we did a lot of research, and I was eating a lot of deer meat and a lot of high-protein animal protein, which, that's the leading cause of kidney stones and your intestines failing you. 

"I had no idea, because I usually eat a lot of fish and a lot of chicken. I wanted to eat more protein, a lot of cleaner protein, so we focused more on that and it ended up backfiring.”

Statistics show that bodybuilders, fighters, and martial artists who used protein supplements have significantly higher rates of kidney disease than the rest of the population.

This can be directly related to too much protein.

What Should You do?

Do yourself a favor and throw out those protein supplement bars, protein drinks, and anything that has added artificial protein. You're getting enough protein in your average diet if you eat meat regularly.

And, we’ll be dealing with vegetarians and alternative protein sources in a future article. In the meantime, read more about what protein does for the body under the Nutrition section.

Loved this? Spread the word

About the author

Christina Major is a Holistic Nutritionist, Naturopath, and herbalist. She owns Crystal Holistic Health, a nutritional consulting and writing business specializing in complementary and alternative medicine. She has over a decade of helping people find health, lose weight, and get off medications. Christina has practiced martial arts for 18 years. Staring with an eclectic group in college, she practiced Tang Soo Do and Tai Kwan Do for three years after graduation. After moving to Central PA, she began studying Taijutsu where she obtained a 2nd-degree black belt and studied the art directly under the Soke and top Shihan in Japan.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Related Articles You Might Like to Read:

Stuff We're Eyeing

Feed Me Fight Me Is Marine Made to Help Veterans

By Jordan Newmark  | 6 March 2021 Feed Me Fight Me is all about the Mission. For John Watkins and Brian Eayrs, who became friends while serving in the US Marine CORPS, [...]

Europe, Where We're Headed

Discover a Unique European Budo Centre – Dojo Stara Wieś

By The Staff  |  26 June 2023 The European Budo Centre - Dojo Stara Wieś is an architectural gem nestled within the picturesque Polish landscape. This facility is designed and built [...]

What We're Reading

What we're reading is made up of books, articles and other reading materials across all fighting disciplines, philosophical perspectives, strategies, tactics and other topics we think you will find of [...]

What We’re Reading

Lifestyle, What We're Watching

Johnnie To’s Throw Down Is the Love Letter Judo Always Deserved

By Eirann Mannino  |  8 April 2021   Despite the prevalent traces of Judo in modern martial arts action choreography, it remains sorely neglected as either a subject or primary martial [...]

Injury Management Posts

How to Prevent MMA Rotator Cuff Injuries?

By Dr. Pamela Fernandes  |  15 June 2021One of the most common shoulder injuries in martial arts is related to the rotator cuff. In karate, the shoulder is the most [...]

Recovery Posts

Combat Arts Workout Recovery Hack – Stay Loose to Win!

By Lisa Stone  |  18 May 2021   Recovery techniques cover many bases. You do not want to wait until you are injured to start thinking about it. In fact, using [...]

Nutrition Posts

Achieve the Ideal You with a Custom Keto Diet

By FAHL Staff  |  15 March 2023 Tired of feeling sluggish and unhealthy? Ready to take control of your eating habits and make positive changes in your life? If so, starting [...]

S&C Posts

Train Like a MMA Fighter: the Ultimate Strength & Conditioning Program

Step into the intense world of MMA, a melting pot of various martial arts disciplines, including Muay Thai, Karate, BJJ, and Boxing. You'll learn that your performance isn't just about [...]