Share this

Reader support is the lifeblood of Fighting Arts Health Lab. At no cost to you, purchases through links on this site earn us a commission.

Bataireacht – The Lost Art of Irish Stick Fighting

By Lewis BuddenUpdated 21 Sep 2026  ·  Originally Published 2 Oct 2020    

Ask most people to name an Irish martial art and you will get a blank look, or a joke about bar fights. That is our loss, and it is worth correcting.

Bataireacht is the Irish term for stick fighting, and the first thing you should know is that it is not one martial art. It is one of the world's many types of martial arts, and a family of them in its own right. Practitioners train with the shillelagh, a stout blackthorn cudgel that doubles as a walking stick, learning strikes, thrusts and blocks, and in most surviving systems they train punches, kicks and grappling right alongside the stick work.

For most of the twentieth century it was very nearly gone. Today a small international community of instructors in Ireland, Canada and the United States is bringing it back, and we spoke with several of them about what that work actually involves.

For most of the twentieth century it was very nearly gone. Today a small international community of instructors in Ireland, Canada and the United States is bringing it back, and we spoke with several of them about what that work actually involves.

Bataireacht Has Deep Roots

How old is the shillelagh? Honestly, nobody can tell you with certainty, and you should be wary of anyone who claims otherwise.

The most frequently cited researcher on the subject, John W. Hurley, argues that shillelagh methods evolved across thousands of years out of older Irish spear, staff, axe and sword fighting, with the weapons shortening over time from long spears and wattles down to the cudgel, the alpeen and the blackthorn walking stick. That is a lineage argument rather than a dated origin, and it is the honest way to frame it.

Like the wider history and evolution of martial arts, the shillelagh's story is shaped as much by politics as by technique. What we can date is the political pressure that shaped the art.

After the Williamite War ended with the Treaty of Limerick in 1691, the Irish Parliament passed a series of anti-Catholic statutes, beginning with the Act for the better securing the government, by disarming papists in September 1695. It required Catholics to surrender all arms and ammunition, and it authorised searches to enforce that surrender. The same body of law barred Catholics from keeping any horse valued above five pounds, which was the threshold for a mount fit for military service, and any Protestant could seize such a horse simply by offering the owner five pounds for it. Catholics were further excluded from bearing arms, from commissions in the army and navy, and from formal education.

Bataireacht O'Hea the Genius of the Bill

Tradition holds that the shillelagh thrived in exactly this gap. A knobbed blackthorn stick was a walking aid, not a weapon on its face, and a man carrying one could pass an inspection and still be armed. We should be clear that this is received wisdom within the stick-fighting community rather than a documented statutory loophole. It is entirely consistent with what the disarmament acts did, and with how common the shillelagh later became, but it is tradition, and we will not dress it up as anything more.

The art's true heyday came later than most accounts suggest. Irish cudgel fencing peaked during the faction-fighting era of the early nineteenth century, when rival groups met by arrangement at fairs, patterns and race meetings. The best-documented rivalry ran between the Caravats, drawn largely from cottiers and landless labourers, and the Shanavests, associated with better-off leaseholding farmers, who clashed across Tipperary, Limerick, Cork and Waterford from around 1806.

These were not brawls in the modern sense. They had leaders, colours, recruitment and a rough code governing who could be attacked and with what.

So what ended it? Not one thing, but several at once. The Catholic Emancipation campaign redirected communal energy into mass politics, the Catholic Church and local elites pushed hard on ideas of respectability, the Royal Irish Constabulary expanded, and then the population collapse and emigration of the Great Famine gutted the rural networks that had sustained the whole practice. The stick went with them.

A word on the name, because you will see it stated with false confidence all over the internet. Most linguists derive "shillelagh" from the Irish sail éille, where sail means willow or cudgel and éille is the genitive of iall, meaning thong, a reference to the wrist strap fitted to many old sticks. A competing tradition, recorded by Anna Maria Hall and Patrick Weston Joyce, links the word instead to the oak forests of the village and barony of Shillelagh in County Wicklow. Some Irish practitioners dismiss the Wicklow story outright as an English invention. We take no side here. The point is that it is genuinely unsettled, and we would rather tell you that than pretend.

The wood, at least, is not in dispute. Shillelaghs were traditionally cut from blackthorn (Prunus spinosa) or oak, with root wood prized because it resists cracking under impact. The classic stick is knotty, with a large knob at the top formed by the root burl where trunk meets root, and that knob is the striking head, not the handle. The bark was peeled, the stick smeared with butter or lard and cured up a chimney, which gave it that characteristic black sheen. Some were hollowed at the knob and filled with molten lead.

Modern Day Bataireacht Warriors

Unlike revived European styles reconstructed from old manuals, the best known surviving bataireacht lineage was never lost at all. It came down by unbroken transmission, father to son, for two centuries.

That system is the Doyle family style, called Rince an Bhata Uisce Bheatha, the Dance of the Whiskey Stick, or simply the "Newfie shillelagh." It is distinguished from most other bataireacht by a two-handed grip and by deep roots in pugilism and boxing footwork.

Where did that two-handed grip come from? The style's own account is specific, and it is more interesting than the usual origin story. According to the Doyle organisation, the founder was a pugilist from a Doyle family in the west of Ireland who was hired to settle disputes between families, and who at times guarded illegal businesses and distilleries. That last detail is offered as one explanation for the word "Whiskey" in the style's nickname. He took the boxing he already knew, applied it to the stick fighting around him, and traded the standard one-handed grip of the bata for a two-handed one. Rince an Bhata Uisce Bheatha was the result.

The word "Dance" was camouflage. According to the late Gregory Doyle, calling it a "Whiskey Stick Dance" raised fewer eyebrows than calling it fighting, which let Doyle men discuss the art openly while keeping the training itself quiet.

It reached Canada in the early 1800s with Maurice Doyle, who settled on Newfoundland's Avalon Peninsula, and it was preserved there through the family while stick fighting faded in Ireland itself.

Glen Doyle, born in Newfoundland in 1965 and now teaching in Ontario, holds the style today. Speaking to Celtic Life International, he described the rule he grew up under: "If you didn't have the surname 'Doyle,' you didn't learn it." His father was strict about it, and Doyle puts the family at five or six generations in Canada. He began stick training in 1972 at seven years old, having already started boxing under his father three years before that. His father, Gregory Doyle, was a boxer and a Canadian Armed Forces veteran who said more than once that stick fighting had saved his life during the Korean War.

Then in 1998, Glen asked his father for permission to teach outside the family. Gregory said no at first, then relented, agreeing that the system could go to anyone with the heart and conviction to preserve it. As such, a rule that had held since the early 1800s was broken deliberately, by the man it was designed to protect.

That decision is why the art exists outside one family today. Glen Doyle remains the system's patriarch, while day-to-day oversight now sits with its chieftain, Bernie Leddy, in Ireland.

Bataireacht Passed Down Among Generations

Why did these techniques survive when so much else did not? The answer practitioners give is brutally simple: what failed in a faction fight did not get taught to anybody's son. What remains is what worked when the stakes were real. That is a persuasive account of how any living combative tradition filters itself, and you hear it echoed right across the shillelagh community.

Preserving a system that way carries an obvious cost, and it is a cost the people in this article have all had to weigh. Keeping lineage and technique intact means resisting the pressure to modernise, to standardise, to commercialise. That is precisely the pressure that has grown as the art's profile has risen.

Bernard "Bernie" Leddy is the clearest example of the tradition crossing back over the water. Originally from County Waterford, he began Shotokan karate at eight, later trained in judo, and spent roughly two decades in aikido, reaching 3rd dan and running a club in Luton, England, before a serious workplace injury took him off the mat entirely. Anyone who has faced a long recovery from a side-lining injury will recognise what happened next.

"I was injured at work, which stopped my training for a couple of years. I had a couple of operations and gained loads of weight. The doctor advised me to lose weight, and so I traveled around looking for a martial art path different from my previous experience, but alas, I could not. Dejected, one night, it struck me that my life had been perpetuating other cultures' martial systems. What about my own Irish culture? I researched Irish martial arts, and up came the Doyle family style. Being a nerd, I researched it and researched it, and contacted Glen Doyle and asked if he would train me, and the rest is history."

Leddy began the Irish revival in Fermanagh, teaching bataireacht in the local hall at Mullaghdun with the stated aim of bringing the art back to Ireland. He has since moved to County Leitrim, where he heads the European branch of the Doyle system and has been named its Chieftain, overseeing standards worldwide. He teaches online and in person across the island, including a regular class in Manorhamilton, and runs an annual week-long coaching intensive at Kiltyclogher, County Leitrim.

His sessions follow a consistent shape. "We start with warmups, then drills, either against pads or sticks. I then work on a topic with attacks and defence, and then we finish on forms, sparring, or competition. Our focus is always to end the fight as fast and as hard as we can. In bataireacht, traditionally you would fight more than one assailant, so we train to fight hard, fast, and conserve energy. I also focus on the self-defence aspect. We are a traditional style, and I don't mix it or dilute it."

Read that again, because it tells you what the training actually demands. Fighting several opponents at once with a two-pound club is an energy-system problem before it is a technique problem, and it is why conditioning sits at the front of every session rather than the end.

Growth of Bataireacht

Leddy's ambition is not a niche following. It is a revival, and he is explicit about it.

"I train prospective coaches here at my home in Leitrim, Ireland. My goal is bringing it back into the Irish mainstream, to make it as common as any other sport but not diluted or corrupted. I want to promote it and to make it accessible to everyone in the community, and to preserve the system for the future."

He has said elsewhere that once people see how effective bataireacht is, they want to know more, and that his twenty-year horizon is to have it in every hall in Ireland, if not the world.

The growth is real and it is measurable. As of late 2025, Leddy had overseen the creation of roughly fifty bataireacht schools and study groups across Ireland, the UK, the United States, Taiwan, Mexico, the Czech Republic and Egypt. Closer to home, he has launched a women's class in Manorhamilton built around self-defence, telling the Leitrim Observer the aim is to equip women with the skills to protect themselves and their families using Ireland's own martial art.

We would also be remiss if we did not say the obvious: this is what a revival looks like when it is driven by people who refuse to let something die rather than by money or by a governing body. And that same expansion is precisely what worries the people who have spent years preserving these systems. We will come back to why.

Evolution of Bataireacht

If bataireacht survived on the shoulders of the families who guarded it, it was rebuilt on the shoulders of the people who wrote it down. And no one has written more of it down than John W. Hurley.

Born in Newark, New Jersey to an Irish immigrant father, Hurley has researched Irish stick fighting since the early 1990s, and he practises the art himself rather than studying it purely from a desk. His four books — Irish Gangs and Stick-Fighting, Shillelagh: The Irish Fighting Stick, The Shillelagh Makers Handbook and Fighting Irish: The Art of Irish Stick-Fighting — form the closest thing the field has to a standard reference, and his own author materials describe him as a foremost authority on the history and culture of traditional Irish martial arts. Nearly every serious modern practitioner, whatever their style, has read him.

What makes the work matter is its argument, not just its detail. Hurley's study sets out to reclaim the shillelagh from caricature — from the Victorian cartoon of the drunken, club-swinging Irishman — and to re-present it as the badge of a genuine martial culture, one built on courage, skill and a code its practitioners called "Shillelagh Law". That reframing, more than any single technique, is what gave the current revival its intellectual footing. You cannot revive an art that everyone believes was only ever a bar brawl. Hurley's research is a large part of why people stopped believing that.

His scholarship also does something quieter and more useful: it goes to the primary sources. His volume on the nineteenth-century Irish author William Carleton — himself a stick-fighter — collects Carleton's stick-fighting tales in one place for the first time, with three hundred endnotes decoding the nineteenth-century Irish and Hiberno-English terms in the text. That is the kind of work a living tradition needs if it is going to reconstruct itself honestly rather than invent a past that flatters it.

If Hurley represents the art's memory, the living practitioners represent its argument with itself — and the sharpest version of that argument is about whether bataireacht should stay sealed off or grow by absorbing the arts around it.

Maxime Chouinard makes the case for keeping it sealed. Based in Kingston, Ontario, Chouinard directs Antrim Bata, a distinct northern Irish stick tradition he learned in Ireland in 2007 from a teacher who has asked not to be named publicly. He also writes the long-running research blog Irish Stick Fighting, which is, in our view, the most rigorous single source on this subject anywhere online — and the natural companion to Hurley's books for anyone who wants to go deeper.

His classes run in twenty-minute blocks: warmup and conditioning, then specific techniques, then focused sparring, then free play. "When I fight, I sometimes use techniques from other arts I know, but I try to separate Antrim Bata from anything else when I teach it."

Unlike most eastern martial arts, there is no universal grading system across bataireacht. In Chouinard's association instructor grades exist, running assistant instructor, instructor, promhadh and máistir, but students are judged on demonstrated skill rather than on belt rank. Protective equipment is standard for sparring: padded fencing masks, padded vests, gloves, and hard protection for the legs and elbows. Full-contact stick sparring puts bataireacht among the more demanding martial arts to train safely.

For all its distinctiveness, Irish stick is not the only European stick tradition, and serious practitioners tend to know the others. The English kept singlestick and great stick, and France produced the grand bâton and the cane work of savate. What sets the surviving Irish styles apart is that they were carried abroad and preserved as living lineages rather than reconstructed from manuals — which is exactly why the question of how much to change them cuts so deeply.

Instruments of Bataireacht

The stick itself remains a craft object, and that matters more than you might expect.

Francis McCaffrey of McCaffrey Crafts is a fifth-generation blackthorn stick maker working from Lower Bridge Street in Killorglin, County Kerry. He produces shillelaghs from roughly eighteen inches through to walking and hiking lengths, in blackthorn and in oak in the older Wicklow style.

Blackthorn is harvested from the wild and then seasoned for years before anyone works it. A genuine stick is noticeably denser and heavier than its dimensions suggest, it shows the trimmed nubs of former thorns along the shaft, and it carries a knob that is the natural root burl rather than a turned or glued addition. Now you know what to look for.

Assorted Shillelagh used in Bataireacht Irish Stick Fighting

Source: Samuraiantiqueworld, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

McCaffrey argues the history deserves to be told properly. "It's paramount that the history of shillelagh Irish stick fighting has a voice. I live and work in Ireland and try to be as vocal as possible on this topic. I find all debate is good once people are thinking about bataireacht."

He also points out that the stick has not been purely ceremonial in his own life. "I've had two instances in recent years where I had to use my blackthorn walking stick quickly in self-defence. Once against an aggressive drunk, and another time against someone trying to get into my premises."

The Future for Tradition 

Bataireacht is in better shape than it has been in a century. It is taught on both sides of the Atlantic, documented by serious researchers, and supplied by working craftspeople who know what they are doing.

So what keeps its teachers up at night? Not obscurity. Distortion. Schools appearing that graft Irish branding onto unrelated stick methods, teaching grips and blocks that were never part of the tradition. The question of what a martial art really is — and what makes one martial art effective rather than merely marketable — sits underneath the whole revival. That concern is not merely territorial, and we want to be clear about why: a wrong grip on a two-pound blackthorn club is a safety problem long before it is an authenticity problem. Somebody's student gets hurt.

The open question, then, is whether an art can grow without hollowing itself out. As Chouinard frames it, the ambition is for bataireacht to be recognised as the martial art it genuinely is, while keeping its identity intact rather than losing it in the trappings of success.

There is a word the Irish use, dúchas, that carries a meaning English struggles with. It means heritage, but also inheritance, native place, and the inborn nature of a thing all at once. It is what you are because of where you come from. Every instructor in this article is wrestling with the same question in one form or another: whether a living tradition can be handed to strangers and still keep its dúchas. We do not know the answer. We suspect they do not either. But we would rather watch them try than watch the art disappear a second time.

FAQs

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a Shillelagh Illegal?

No, owning a shillelagh, which is a traditional Irish walking stick or club, is generally not illegal. However, regulations regarding carrying or using it as a weapon may vary depending on local laws and circumstances.

Can You Take a Shillelagh on a Plane?

Generally, it is not advisable to bring a shillelagh on a plane as a carry-on item. Airport security regulations typically prohibit carrying any objects that can be used as weapons, including clubs or batons. It is best to check with the specific airline and airport security guidelines for clarity on what is permitted.

What are Irish Warriors Called?

Irish warriors are commonly referred to as "Gaelic warriors" or "Celtic warriors." They were known for their bravery, combat skills, and fierce dedication to their clans and kings. Additionally, specific groups like the Fianna or the Red Branch Knights are notable in Irish mythology and history for their martial prowess.

Featured Image Source: Francisco Goya, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Loved this? Spread the word


About the Author

Lewis Budden

Lewis Budden

MMA Culture Writer & Karate Black Belt

Lewis Budden is a culture writer based in the north of England, where he reports on the strange and wonderful stories of MMA across Northern Europe. He has trained in Shukokai Karate for twelve years and holds a black belt in the discipline, with a particular interest in how traditional styles like Wing Chun have taken root in British cities.


Stories Other Readers are Checking Out:

Far East - Where We're Headed

Cebu ‒ World’s Arnis Capital & the Perfect Martial Arts Destination

By Sonia Ahmed  ·  12 Sep 2020

Renowned as the queen of the South, Cebu is the port capital and the oldest city in Cebu province. Located in the Central Visayas, it’s the country’s most developed area, [...]

Movies We're Watching

Johnnie To’s Throw Down Is the Love Letter Judo Always Deserved

By Éireann Mannino  ·  16 Jul 2023

Despite the prevalent traces of Judo in modern martial arts action choreography, it remains sorely neglected as either a subject or primary martial art across the whole of cinema. Johnnie [...]

Strength and Conditioning

How to Do the Splits Safely, Front and Middle, With Stretches That Work

By Sandy Cochran  ·  17 Nov 2026

Learning how to do the splits is one of the most common flexibility goals in martial arts, and one of the most oversold. Search for it and you will find [...]

Middle East - Where We're Headed

Behold the Unspoiled Beauty of Jeddah & it’s Budding MMA Scene

By Sonia Ahmed  ·  19 Sep 2020

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has been making news for opening its borders for recreational tourism. Until 2018, it issued visas only for pilgrimages, business matters, sports events, and foreign [...]

Americas - Where We're Headed

Chris Rini Finds Art in MMA Violence

By Jordan Newmark  ·  14 May 2021

Imagine the sport of Mixed Martial Arts is a house. The foundation is the rules, the walls and floors are the fighters, and the roof is the promoters. Maybe, the [...]

Nutrition

Top 12 Reasons To Add Fennel Seeds To Your Food

By Christina Major  ·  30 Aug 2024

One of the primary ingredients in Dit Da Jow, fennel seeds are healthy and have massive health benefits that can help prepare you for a fight, may prevent bruising, and [...]

Europe - Where We're Headed

Discover a Unique European Budo Centre – Dojo Stara Wieś

By John Wes Green  ·  26 Jun 2023

The European Budo Centre - Dojo Stara Wieś is an architectural gem nestled within the picturesque Polish landscape. This facility is designed and built according to the principles of Japanese [...]

Stuff We're Learning

How to Do a Roundhouse Kick in Muay Thai and Taekwondo

By John Wes Green  ·  19 Nov 2026

The roundhouse kick is the first kick most people learn and the one they spend years fixing. It swings in from the side, turns the whole body behind it, and [...]

Injury Management

Preventing Sudden Cardiac Arrests in Martial Arts

By Dr. Pamela Fernandes  ·  14 Feb 2025

In June 2021, the world watched in horror as Danish footballer Christian Eriksen suffered a sudden cardiac arrest during a Euro 2020 match. This shocking incident highlighted the importance of [...]

Oceania - Where We're Headed

Title Bout Aside, Mental Health Remains Megan Anderson’s Biggest Fight

By Jordy McElroy  ·  31 Oct 2020

Megan Anderson fears no woman. Even with a scheduled December bout against Amanda Nunes — a two-division UFC champion that napalms faces for a living — a dauntless Megan Anderson [...]

Books We're Reading

Mastering the Mat: Jiu Jitsu University Revolutionary Approach

By John Wes Green  ·  25 Aug 2024

"Jiu-Jitsu University" by Saulo Ribeiro and Kevin Howell is a comprehensive and transformative guide to Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu (BJJ), authored by one of the sport's most accomplished and respected figures. Six-time [...]

Africa - Where We're Headed

Explore Great Pyramids & Learn an Ancient Egyptian Martial Art Tahtib

By Sonia Ahmed  ·  1 Sep 2020

Egypt is home to one of the world’s earliest civilizations. The country has seven UNESCO World Heritage sites. There’s hardly anyone in the world who doesn’t know about Egyptian pharaohs [...]

Workout Recovery

Combat Arts Workout Recovery Hack – Stay Loose to Win!

By Lisa Stone  ·  18 May 2021

Recovery techniques cover many bases. You do not want to wait until you are injured to start thinking about it. In fact, using proactive or preemptive recovery methods daily is [...]

Staff Reviews

Feed Me Fight Me Is Marine Made to Help Veterans

By Jordan Newmark  ·  6 Mar 2021

Feed Me Fight Me is all about the Mission.  For John Watkins and Brian Eayrs, who became friends while serving in the US Marine CORPS, their burgeoning business’ mission is [...]